top of page

Poverty in Brazil 

What do human rights look like for people living under the poverty line in Brazil?

It is impossible to picture a stereotypical “poor person” because poverty affects people from all backgrounds. It does not discriminate between gender, race, ethnicity, sexuality, nor ability. However, due to systemic imbalances, certain people are more likely than others to live with diminished economic means and social mobility. Furthermore, once a person or family enters the cycle of poverty, it becomes more and more difficult to extricate themselves from the system of disadvantages. Poverty disproportionately affects minorities, particularly those mentioned on the other pages of this website, and this page serves to discuss some of the common problems those living under the poverty line face in their daily lives.

Fast Facts

  • According to the World Bank, poverty is defined as living off of less than $5.50 per day

    • 52.9 million people (26.5% of the population) live below the poverty line in Brazil

  • Extreme poverty means living off of less than $1.90 per day​

    • 15.2 million people (7.7% of the population) lives in extreme poverty​

  • 85.93% of Brazilians live in urban areas​

  • The unemployment rate is 12.4%, or just over 13 million people, according to Trading Economics

  • According to the Rio Times, "among the people with the ten percent lowest income in the country, 78.5 percent are black or mixed race, while 20.8 percent are white

Lack of Basic Resources

The over 50 million people living in poverty in Brazil face a collection of common problems relating to access to basic resources. Food insecurity, unsafe housing, barriers to quality education, and lack of legal documentation of citizenship combine to perpetuate problems from generation to generation.

​

First, food insecurity and malnutrition affects not only physical wellbeing, but mental health as well. Poor diets cause immune deficiencies, which lead to health complications and higher rates of disease. Children also suffer cognitive developmental delays that affect their entire lives. When the physical and mental challenges combine, it makes people without access to nutritious food overall less productive. Therefore, they are not upwardly mobile and are less likely to progress into a higher socioeconomic class, and the cycle repeats and worsens, like an ever tightening spiral of poor health. For a more detailed explanation of the cycle of malnutrition, check out the video to the left.

​

Second, unsafe, unreliable housing negatively impacts poor people physically and economically. It is estimated that there is a housing deficit of approximately seven million units in Brazil, and 20 percent of its total population lives in inadequate housing. Favelas, or slums, have widely become the “solution” to the housing crisis, but there are several problems with this system. First, favelas are technically considered illegal, but a lack of city planning during a period of rapid urbanization left people without other options. Second, favelas often lack basic infrastructure, such as sewage systems, potable water, and waste management. This often leads to higher levels of disease, and little to no government intervention results in high crime levels as well. Third, even if someone is relatively safe and healthy, living in such stressful environments negatively impacts their mental health and therefore overall productivity.

 

Next, access to quality education, which is necessary for social advancement, is difficult to guarantee. In Brazil, public education is free until college. However, schools are funded by municipal and state budgets, so poorer states have worse schools. Therefore, middle and upper class families tend to send their children to private schools which have more resources and better teachers. In comparison, public schools tend to lack resources such as books, are often closed to due nearby violence, and their teachers tend to have minimal hands-on training before entering the classroom. Due to these differences, the OECD estimated that children in Brazilian public schools are almost three years behind their peers as of age 15. Furthermore, even if children are enrolled in schools, those from large, poor families often begin work around age ten—despite child labor laws outlawing the practice until age 16—and thus are largely unable to benefit from them.

 

Finally, in order for people to benefit from government programs that are designed to mitigate any of the above challenges, they must have proper documentation to prove they are citizens. However, poor people, particularly in rural areas, are often born outside of hospitals and are therefore never counted by the government. Additionally, for those in urban areas who live in favelas, their residences aren’t legally recognized, so they don’t have legal recourse for issues nor an address to list on other paperwork. Finally, if people have never formally entered the workforce, and thus do not have a work card or other official documentation, they are often disenfranchised and discriminated against in the judicial system.

 

Inevitably, poverty will affect people from different backgrounds and identities differently. However, there are still several factors that cause similar problems for those living under the poverty line. Access to basic resources including sufficient and nutritional food, stable housing, quality education, and proper documentation can make a world of difference, yet unfortunately, too many Brazilians do not have the access they deserve. 

Wealth Inequality

​​

 

In a somewhat meager, but still meaningful effort to combat inequality, the Brazilian government implemented the Bolsa Familia program. This program dedicates 0.5 percent of the GDP to wealth redistribution. Parents receive a monthly cash grant that can be used in any way they sees fit, just so long as their children are vaccinated and enrolled in school. The grant is not enough to support a family, but it provides a safety net if a crisis arises or economic situations change abruptly. The program has been widely successful and is quite popular, but it isn’t enough to completely change the imbalance.

MGWG_SC_L07_A002901.jpg

​Despite a recent period of economic growth, Brazil is now in the midst of a recession which is exacerbating existing wealth inequalities. Even during the time of expansion, it is estimated that the “wealthiest ten percent of Brazilians received the benefit of 61 percent of economic growth.” While poverty as a whole decreased, the poorest in society didn’t equally benefit from the country’s overall success. Oxfam even calculated that the six wealthiest Brazilians have the same wealth as the 100 million poorest citizens. Moving forward, this concentration of wealth will likely only continue to grow due to austerity measures placed on welfare programs such as public healthcare and education coupled with the extreme political power of those at the top of the socioeconomic scale.

Government and Poverty

While the government of Brazil is taking some actions to protect the wellbeing of its poorer citizens, there are still many ways that it both neglects and actively harms those most vulnerable. There are systemic abuses of minorities and people living in poverty such as the ineffective criminal justice system. Additionally, the new regime of recently elected President Jair Bolsonaro has negatively impacted those in lower socioeconomic classes. And finally, recent state-sponsored international events such as the FIFA World Cup and the Olympics have caused further harm to the poor, particularly in Rio de Janeiro. 

 

First, as mentioned on previous pages of this website, the criminal justice system is in dire need of reform. According to the Human Rights Watch, Brazilian prisons are currently at 197% capacity, and as of June 2016, as many as 40% of incarcerated people had not been convicted and were simply awaiting trial. Due to discriminatory laws and practices, racial and ethnic minorities and poor people without proper documentation are overrepresented in prison populations. Then, not only are they mistreated while captive because of overcrowding and understaffing, but they are permanently disenfranchised because convicted criminals are not allowed to vote.

 

Next, the rhetoric and actions of President Bolsonaro have caused the Human Rights Watch to be on alert. Bolsonaro is openly in favor of torture, allowing police officers to “kill first, ask questions later,” has repeatedly demeaned minorities, including women, the LGBTQ+ community, afro-Brazilians, and indigenous people, and called to end “all activism” in Brazil. Currently Brazil has a higher rate of police killings than the Philippines, and this is likely to climb thanks to his new policies. Additionally, regardless of Bolsonaro’s official actions, his rhetoric has already led to an increase in extra-governmental abuses of the most vulnerable members of society.

Furthermore, in the name of tourism and international recognition, the Brazilian government has applied for and subsequently hosted several large-scale events. The 2014 FIFA World Cup and the 2016 Summer Olympic Games were ostensibly hosted in Brazil to increase tourism revenue, but the corporations gained while the country lost. According to CNBC, Brazil spent over $15 billion USD, and as per the Council on Foreign Relations, over $20 billion USD on the Olympic games. Giant stadiums were constructed and then abandoned because they are too large to be filled for a normal event. Transportation infrastructure was built through favelas to be used twice by tourists and never by local residents. Athlete housing was meant to be used by citizens, but instead 77,000 people were forced to leave their homes in Rio. On top of everything else, tickets for these events are much more expensive than the average Brazilian can afford. For a comedic explanation of just how damaging the World Cup was for Brazil, watch the video to the left, in particular from 1:48 to 5:54.

Overall, the Brazilian government has made some attempts at improving the lives of its poorest constituents. Nonetheless, it remains largely complicit in many people’s suffering due to intentional and unconscious actions that disproportionately harm marginalized members of society.  Once again, poverty does not solely affect one type of person and no two people’s experiences with poverty are identical. However, there are shared experiences, positive and negative, that stem from socioeconomic hardship, and some are made more extreme by the government’s actions or inactions.

Moving Forward

Aside from programs like Bolsa Familia, many nonprofit organizations are also working to improve the lives of poor Brazilians. If you are interested in learning more, donating money, or volunteering your time, you can visit:

​

cfi.jpeg
pf.jpeg
Screen Shot 2019-04-25 at 8.40.15 PM.png

​

CARE Brazil 

​

​

Project Favela

​

​

ChildFund International

© 2023 by Going Places. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page